top of page
Search

Prediction Markets and Problem Gambling: How "Trading" on Events Can Become a Gambling Problem

Writer: Jeffrey Reynolds
Jeffrey Reynolds
11 minutes ago
4 min read

predictions market graphic

Prediction markets are everywhere. Apps like Kalshi and Polymarket let people buy and sell contracts on whether a team will win, a politician will be elected or the temperature will hit a certain number. The companies call it trading. Addiction counselors, regulators and the National Council on Problem Gambling (NCPG) increasingly call it something else. The link between prediction markets and problem gambling is now one of the most urgent questions in the field.


What Are Prediction Markets?

A prediction market lets users buy “event contracts” that pay out if something happens. Prediction markets are regulated federally as financial products, not as gambling, and Kalshi was approved by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission in 2020. Fortune reported that Kalshi holds roughly 89 percent of the U.S. market and that about 90 percent of its wagers are on sports.

That legal label matters because state-licensed sportsbooks must follow responsible gambling rules, such as age limits and self-exclusion programs. The NCPG has pointed out that prediction markets regulated by the CFTC lack the same responsible gaming requirements.


Why Experts Call It Gambling

In September, NCPG board president Derek Longmeier said prediction markets are “functionally gambling” however they are classified legally, adding: “The harm is not theoretical, and we cannot wait to act.” Earlier, the council said trading event contracts carries “substantially similar levels of risk to the consumer as traditional sports betting.”


Kalshi disputes the comparison. Because traders bet against each other and not against the house, a spokesperson told Fortune, “There’s no banning winners and hooking losers.” The company says it offers self-exclusion and self-limit tools.


Six Ways Prediction Markets Can Lead to Problem Gambling


1. It doesn’t feel like gambling. The NCPG warns that consumers “may not recognize their activity as functionally gambling,” which can make them less likely to set limits or seek help. Therapist Lin Sternlicht told Fortune that “there’s a strong stigma tied to sports betting, but prediction markets tend to feel more socially acceptable.”


2. There is always something to bet on. Election results, weather, Bitcoin prices and entertainment awards are all available. Fortune described a young man who started with election bets, then chased losses with weather and Bitcoin wagers and lost about $10,000 in five months. Chasing losses is a classic warning sign of problem gambling.


3. Younger people can get in. According to Fortune, Kalshi allows users from age 18, while sports betting in most states is limited to people 21 and older. The NCPG argues access should start at 21, citing research that “young people are at greater risk of developing gambling problems.” A Michigan treatment specialist told WXYZ that the apps pose a particular risk to teens and people in their early 20s, whose brains are still developing.


4. It is fast and frictionless. A recovery coach interviewed by WXYZ said he could lose $10,000 “in one second” on these apps. Money moves like a number on a screen, and there is no casino to leave.


5. Features can keep people engaged. Fortune reported that Kalshi pays a 3.25 percent yield on balances above $250, which one user said kept him betting. Heavy advertising and celebrity promotions add to the pull. Arizona State’s Cronkite News reported that the NBA announced partnerships with Kalshi and Polymarket in October, drawing criticism from public health advocates.


6. Help is harder to find. The NCPG wants prediction markets to display the national helpline, 1-800-MY-RESET. Critics also say these platforms lack built-in help resources and easy self-exclusion, and that deleting an app does not remove a funded account the way closing a sportsbook account can.


Warning Signs of Problem Gambling on Prediction Markets


Signs of problem gambling and prediction markets use the same pattern as other forms of gambling:

  • Spending more time or money than planned

  • Chasing losses with bigger or riskier bets

  • Hiding activity from family and friends

  • Borrowing money or draining savings to keep trading

  • Feeling anxious or irritable when not betting

  • Calling it “investing” or “trading” to avoid admitting it is gambling


A Legal Fight With Public Health Stakes


Whether prediction markets are gambling is also being argued in court. In March, Arizona’s attorney general filed criminal charges against Kalshi, the first state to bring charges against a federally regulated prediction market exchange, and Washington’s attorney general sued the same month, according to Cronkite News. A federal judge temporarily blocked Arizona from enforcing its gambling laws in May, and the state appealed. In August, Connecticut sued Kalshi as well. Kalshi argues that federal commodities law prevents states from applying their gambling laws to its exchange.


However the courts rule, the health question is separate. A person can lose control of his spending on a platform that is legal. Problem gambling doesn’t wait for a ruling.


What This Means for Families


Because prediction markets are marketed as finance, parents and partners may not realize what they’re seeing. A son who spends hours watching a “portfolio” and talks about “positions” may be gambling. Ask direct questions, look for new accounts and deposits, and talk about it without blame.


Where to Get Help


If you or someone you care about is struggling with problem gambling and prediction markets, help is available. Call or text the National Problem Gambling Helpline at 1-800-MY-RESET, talk to a counselor with training in gambling disorder, and consider peer support such as Gamblers Anonymous or Gam-Anon for families. Our problem gambling self-test can help you take an honest look at your own behavior.


Prediction markets may be legal, innovative and genuinely useful to some people. They can also be gambling by another name, and treating them that way is the first step toward preventing harm.



 
 
 

Comments


Site Links

Connect with us

SUBSCRIBE

Thanks for subscribing!

Causation, LLC does not endorse nor control the content, products or services of other sites linked to or from ProblemGambling.com. This site is intended to facilitate the dissemination of information about problem gambling, it's prevention and treatment. The information, including but not limited to, text, graphics, images and other material contained on this website are for informational purposes only AND is NOT intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.

View our Privacy Policy. 

© 2023-2027 Causation, LLC All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page